Book a consult

Jewish community · November 19, 2026

Should I talk to my rabbi or a therapist?

You can talk to both. A question of halacha (Jewish law) goes to your own rav (your rabbi), and in therapy with me we work on the patterns that keep you stuck and on practical coping skills that fit your values and goals.

If you’d rather talk it through than read about it, the first conversation is free and takes 15 minutes.

When a question touches on halacha, I'm glad to consult your rav, with your permission, so your therapy and your practice point the same way. My goal is to support your goals.

Is this a question of halacha, or about how I'm coping?

If you want to know what halacha says, that's a question for your rav. Whether something is permitted on Shabbos (the Sabbath) is one example.

If it's about how you're coping, you can bring it to therapy. The tension that builds before a family Shabbos meal is one example, and so is a pattern you keep repeating at work or at home. Family expectations, dating, religious identity, faith transitions and community pressures are among the things I work with.

Therapy with me starts with getting to know your story: what brought you to this point, what you've already tried, and what you'd like to be different. Then we decide where to begin, and go at a pace that suits you.

You may already talk with your rav about what you're carrying. Nothing here says to stop.

Some things are both. A family disagreement can have a halachic question inside it, and a decision about your practice can strain things at home. In therapy we work on the strain and the patterns around it, and the halachic question stays with your rav.

What one study found

One study speaks to the worry that trusting your rav and going to therapy pull against each other. The authors of a survey published in 2024, of 94 Jewish adults in the United States, about one in ten of them Orthodox, expected that people who trusted their rabbi more would think less of therapy. Their first analysis found no clear link either way. A second analysis, which took gender into account, found a modest link the other way: more trust in one's rabbi went with a more positive attitude toward seeking therapy [Berman and Woolley, 2024].

It's one small study, most of the people in it were not Orthodox, and it can't say which causes which.

Starting with either one

If you start with your rav, you can say you're thinking about therapy too, and ask whether they know someone. Wherever a name comes from, check the license and ask your questions on a first call; the guide to finding a therapist who understands Orthodox Judaism lists them.

If you start with a therapist, tell them a rav is part of your life. Then ask these on the first call, mine included:

  • What happens when something we talk about touches on halacha?
  • If I'd like you to speak with my rav, how does that work?
  • What stays private, and what are the exceptions? The confidentiality guide has more to ask.

If you're worried a therapist would steer your practice somewhere you didn't choose, the guide to whether therapy will change your religious beliefs covers what to listen for.

I consult your rav only with your permission.

What to do this week

  • Write what's weighing on you in one sentence.
  • Mark the part, if any, that's a question of halacha, for your rav.
  • Mark the part that's about how you're coping or what keeps repeating, and decide whether you'd like help with it.
  • If you'd like your rav and a therapist to talk, decide what you'd be comfortable having them share.

When to reach out

If it can't wait, don't stop to work out who to call. In a crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), or call 911 or go to your nearest emergency room.

If you'd like to ask how I'd consult your rav when a question touches on halacha, bring it to a free 15-minute consult, online for adults in New York and California.

Common questions

Can my therapist talk to my rabbi?

With me, yes, with your permission. When a question touches on halacha, I'm glad to consult your rav so your therapy and your practice point the same way.

Can I see a therapist without my rabbi knowing?

From my side, yes. What you share stays confidential and isn't passed to family, a shadchan (a matchmaker) or anyone else without your permission. That includes your rav. The only exceptions are a risk of harm to yourself or others, or where the law requires it.

What if my rabbi and my therapist seem to disagree?

You can say so to each of them. If the disagreement touches on halacha, I'm glad to consult your rav, with your permission, so your therapy and your practice point the same way.

Can my rabbi refer me to a therapist?

You can ask. Whoever gives you a name, the license check and the first-call questions are the same.

More on this site

Sources

  • Berman and Woolley, “Barriers to Initiating Psychotherapy Faced by Jewish-Identified People in the United States”, Journal of Religion and Health 64(1), 2025, published online 2024. Read it
  • Mattie Chein, LCSW, Therapy for Jewish Adults: when I consult your rav, how the work follows your goals, privacy and its exceptions, and the free consult. Read it

Back to all guides

Reading is a first step. Talking is the next.

Book a free 15-minute consult whenever you'd like to talk it through.
Book a free 15-minute consult